- "The Haunted Guitar" - A lazy boy named Jeffery obtains a guitar that was owned by a deceased old blues musician named Memphis Willy.
- "Tune in Tomorrow" - A girl named Elizabeth is obsessed with a reality TV show called Looking for Tomorrow. But what happens when things begin to get a little too real?
- "Live Bait" - Two boys vacationing at a lake end up involved in catching a large fish.
- "Something Strange About Marci" - An unseen narrator investigates how a girl named Marci arrived in town with no family.
- "The Ghost Sitter" - Two boys learn about a ghost that haunts the house next door to them.
- "Fun With Spelling" - A girl receives a book of spells from her gross aunt where the spells actually work.
- "Matt's Lunch Box" - A boy receives a new lunch box that contains strange inhabitants that want to be fed.
- "Stuck in 1957" - A girl puts on some sunglasses that transport her to 1957.
- "Mirror Mirror on the Wall" - A beautiful girl named Bonnie discovers that the reflection in her mirror is alive.
- "What's Cooking?" - Two kids learn the legend of a lunch lady called Chop Suey and the events that would summon her.
The story Fun With Spelling was ghostwritten by author Carolyn Crimi, an author who also ghostwrote two books in the Ghosts of Fear Street series. It is currently unknown if any other stories from this book were ghostwritten.