- Melody Johnson as Samantha
- Ellen-Ray Hennessy as Clarissa
- Susan Cooke as Judith
- Robin Weekes as Cory
- Simone Rosenberg as Anna Frost
- Catherine Fitch as Coach
Differences from the book
- Samantha is not unnaturally tall.
- In the book, Clarissa is a kindly, old woman who uses a crystal ball to grant wishes. On the TV show, Clarissa is a pale, middle-aged woman dressed in black, feathered clothes (the end where a crow perches on top of Judith's head when she turns into a statue, implies that Clarissa is a crow turned human) who gives Samantha a red amulet that glows whenever she makes a wish. The Goosebumps movie has Clarissa as a young, Goth woman who uses a crystal ball to make wishes.
- In the book, Samantha's first wish to be the best player on her basketball team ends up with everyone except her getting sick (and later, Judith accusing Samantha of being a witch, which prompts Samantha to wish that everyone would leave her alone). In the episode, the first wish was kept, but the end result was everyone on the team being as clumsy and incompetent at basketball as Samantha is.
- In the book, Samantha's second wish after being humiliated at the basketball game and Judith accusing Samantha of being a witch was that everyone leave her alone, which ends up with everyone except for Samantha and Clarissa as the only people left in the world. On the TV episode, Samantha's second wish was for everyone to buzz off, which causes everyone except her and Clarissa to turn into flies.
- The ending in the episode is altered. In the book, Judith's first wish from Clarissa is for Samantha to "Fly away, Byrd!" Samantha is then turned into a crow. In the television adaptation, Judith's first wish is to be so beautiful that people will come and admire her no matter where she is in the world, ending with Judith becoming a park statue.
- Samantha's brother (Ron), father, and dog do not appear in the episode.
- In the book Samantha had blonde hair and Judith had red hair, but in the television episode, Samantha has red hair and Judith has blonde hair.
|Title||Release date||Media type|
|September 13, 2011||DVD|
|August 26, 2014||DVD|
- This episode was adapted into Goosebumps Presents book #8.
- Robin Weekes (Cory) would later on play Nathan in "The House of No Return".
- The school that was used to film Montrose Middle School is John English Junior Middle School in Etobicoke, Toronto, Ontario.